You are currently viewing Invoice Discounting Pros and Cons for FMCG Businesses

Invoice Discounting Pros and Cons for FMCG Businesses

Practical cash flow management is crucial, especially for fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) businesses that operate on slim margins and require high liquidity. Invoice discounting is one of the most popular financing solutions for FMCG businesses to optimise their working capital. With the rising inventory, marketing, and logistics costs, many FMCG companies in India are turning to this financial tool to bridge short-term cash flow gaps without waiting for their customers to pay outstanding invoices.

This blog details the pros and cons of invoice discounting for FMCG businesses. It targets investors, financial professionals, and tech enthusiasts looking to understand the strategic benefits and potential pitfalls of this financing option. By the end of this post, you’ll have a comprehensive understanding of how invoice discounting works, its cost considerations, and practical tips for using it effectively.

What is Invoice Discounting?

Invoice discounting is a short-term financing structure in which businesses use their unpaid invoices as collateral to receive cash advances. It allows a business to convert its accounts receivables into immediate cash, providing the liquidity needed for daily operations or strategic investments. This method is particularly beneficial for FMCG companies, which often operate with large volumes of credit sales and must manage their cash flow effectively.

For example, consider an FMCG distributor supplying packaged goods to several retail chains. If these retail clients have a credit period of 30 to 60 days, the distributor might face a cash crunch during that period. The distributor can unlock the cash in those credit sales by seamlessly using invoice discounting and continuing operations.

Purpose and Benefits of Invoice Discounting

The primary purpose of invoice discounting is to enhance cash flow by accessing funds tied up in unpaid invoices. This is especially relevant for FMCG businesses with high sales turnover and need a continuous cash flow for smooth operations. Some key benefits include:

  • Quick Access to Cash: Unlike traditional loans, which involve long approval processes, invoice discounting offers faster access to capital.
  • There is no need for Significant Collateral. The only collateral required is a valid commercial invoice, which reduces the dependency on other assets.
  • Flexibility: Businesses can utilise the funds for various purposes, such as purchasing inventory, paying suppliers, or investing in growth opportunities.

Types of Invoice Discounting

There are primarily two types of invoice discounting:

  1. Full Invoice Discounting:
    • Definition: Businesses discount all their invoices, similar to a line of credit.
    • Usage: Ideal for larger FMCG companies with a high volume of invoices.
    • Benefit: Provides consistent cash flow, ensuring smooth operations.
  2. Selective Invoice Discounting:
    • Definition: Businesses choose specific invoices for discounting based on their cash flow needs.
    • Usage: Suitable for smaller FMCG firms that want to maintain control over specific invoices.
    • Benefit: Allows more flexibility and control over financing costs.

Cost Considerations in Invoice Discounting

One key aspect to consider is the cost associated with invoice discounting. Typically, the fee ranges from 3% to 5% of the invoice value, but this can vary based on factors like company size, sector, and market rates.

  1. Full Invoice Discounting Costs: This option comes with ongoing administration fees and discounting charges, making it more suited for businesses with a large volume of high-value invoices.
  2. Selective Invoice Discounting Costs: Involves a single fee based on the value of the selected invoices, providing a cost-effective solution for businesses with occasional cash flow needs.

Example: If an FMCG company discounts an invoice worth ₹10,00,000 at a 4% fee, it would incur a ₹40,000 cost. This cost should be compared with the benefits of maintaining liquidity.

Pros of Invoice Discounting for FMCG Businesses

Invoice discounting has emerged as a popular and effective financing option, especially for FMCG businesses, due to its ability to unlock cash flow tied up in unpaid invoices quickly. Let’s delve deeper into the fundamental advantages of invoice discounting for FMCG companies.

  1. Enhanced Cash Flow

One of the most significant advantages of invoice discounting is that it enhances cash flow by converting credit sales into immediate cash. FMCG businesses typically operate on high sales turnover with tight margins, often offering credit to their distributors and retailers. This credit period can range between 30 and 90 days, during which the FMCG company’s cash is tied up. With invoice discounting, businesses can easily access up to 80% to 90% of the invoice value in money.

Example: Consider an FMCG company supplying products to a major retail chain with a 60-day credit period. Without invoice discounting, the company would have to wait two months to receive the payment, causing a cash crunch for day-to-day operations. With invoice discounting, the company can receive a substantial portion of the invoice value in advance, enabling it to continue operations without interruption.

Key Benefit: Enhanced cash flow allows the company to pay suppliers on time, meet operational expenses, and invest in strategic growth opportunities like launching new products or entering new markets.

  1. Faster Access to Funds

Traditional business loans require a verbose application and approval process, usually taking weeks or even months. In contrast, invoice discounting provides fast access to funds, usually within 24 to 48 hours of submitting the invoices for review. This quick turnaround is particularly beneficial for FMCG businesses needing immediate cash to capitalise on market opportunities, such as stocking inventory for a festive season or funding a marketing campaign for a new product launch.

Example: If an FMCG company is launching a new product line during the festive season and needs additional funds to ramp up production, waiting for customer payments could mean missing out on peak demand. Invoice discounting ensures that the company has the necessary liquidity to meet the surge in demand.

Key Benefit: Speed and efficiency in obtaining funds help FMCG companies remain agile and responsive to market changes, ensuring they take advantage of critical business opportunities.

  1. No Major Collateral Requirement

Unlike traditional loans that often require businesses to pledge valuable assets like property, machinery, or inventory as collateral, invoice discounting requires no primary collateral other than unpaid invoices. This reduces the risk for the FMCG business and makes it easier to access funding. Since FMCG companies often work on high-volume, low-margin models, they may have little assets to pledge, making invoice discounting a suitable option.

Example: A small-scale FMCG distributor with limited assets can still leverage invoice discounting because a valid invoice from a trusted customer is the only collateral needed. This allows even asset-light FMCG businesses to benefit from improved cash flow.

Key Benefit: This financing method is less risky and more accessible, especially for small and medium-sized FMCG businesses that lack substantial fixed assets.

  1. Confidentiality

Invoice discounting operates confidentially, meaning the business retains complete control over customer relationships. In invoice discounting, the financier does not interact with customers; the company manages its sales ledger and collects payments as usual. This contrasts invoice factoring, where the financier takes over the sales ledger and directly contacts customers for payment, potentially harming the business-client relationship.

Example: If an FMCG company has a strong relationship with its distributors and retailers, it may want a third-party financier to avoid getting involved in the collection process, which could cause confusion or signal financial distress. With invoice discounting, the company’s clients must know that financing is being used, preserving customer trust and business reputation.

Key Benefit: The discreet nature of invoice discounting helps businesses maintain brand integrity and client confidence.

  1. Opportunity for Growth

Access to fast and flexible funding can allow FMCG companies to expand their operations, explore new markets, and seize growth opportunities. With improved cash flow, FMCG businesses can invest in research and development (R&D), expand distribution networks, or scale production to meet growing demand.

Example: Suppose an FMCG company wants to enter a new geographic region but needs additional funds for marketing and distribution setup. Invoice discounting provides the necessary liquidity, enabling the company to grow without waiting for existing invoices to be paid.

Key Benefit: The freedom to allocate funds to growth-oriented projects enables FMCG companies to remain competitive in a dynamic market.

  1. Control Over Receivables

One of the immediate concerns for businesses using external financing is the potential loss of control over receivables. With invoice discounting, however, the business retains complete control over its sales ledger and collection process. This means the company independently decides which invoices to discount and manages customer payments.

Example: An FMCG company that wants to maintain a personal touch in its interactions with key distributors can use selective invoice discounting. This allows the company to choose which invoices to discount without handing over the entire sales ledger to a third party. This control over receivables allows the company to maintain strong customer relationships.

Key Benefit: Businesses can continue to handle their collections, ensuring that customer relationships and credit control remain intact.

  1. Encourages Enhanced Credit Sales

Improved cash flow through invoice discounting enables FMCG companies to offer more competitive credit terms to their trusted partners. Many FMCG companies struggle to extend longer credit periods due to liquidity concerns. However, with access to immediate funds through invoice discounting, businesses can afford to extend credit sales without straining their cash reserves.

Example: An FMCG manufacturer offering 60-day credit terms to a significant retail chain can confidently do so without worrying about cash shortages, thanks to invoice discounting. This flexibility can help the business build stronger relationships with key customers and even negotiate better sales volumes.

Key Benefit: By offering longer credit terms, businesses can attract and retain high-value customers, boosting their sales and market presence.

  1. Flexible Usage

The funds obtained through invoice discounting can be used for various purposes, including purchasing raw materials, paying off suppliers, or investing in new product development. This flexibility allows FMCG businesses to allocate funds according to their current needs.

Example: A seasonal spike in demand might require an FMCG business to stock up on inventory quickly. Instead of seeking a traditional loan, the company can use invoice discounting to obtain the necessary funds and manage seasonal fluctuations effectively.

Key Benefit: The versatile nature of the funds permits businesses to adjust to changing market demands, ensuring continuous operations.

Cons of Invoice Discounting for FMCG Businesses

While invoice discounting offers several benefits for businesses looking to improve their cash flow, it is essential to consider the potential downsides before adopting this financing strategy, especially in the context of fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) businesses. Here are the detailed cons of using invoice discounting:

  1. Costly for Companies with Low Credit Scores

Explanation: One of the most significant disadvantages of invoice discounting is that it can become expensive for companies with poor credit scores. The perceived risk of the business often determines the discount rate applied to each invoice. If the company has a low credit rating, lenders consider it a higher risk, leading to increased fees and interest rates.

For instance, an FMCG distributor with a low credit score might end up paying up to 8% or more in fees compared to a standard 3-5% for companies with a strong credit history. This can significantly impact profitability, especially for smaller FMCG businesses with limited cash reserves.

  • Practical Impact: An FMCG company with thin profit margins may find these additional costs cutting deeply into their earnings, making it harder to sustain operations and grow the business.
  • Example: If an FMCG business discounts an invoice worth ₹10,00,000 at an 8% fee (due to a low credit score), the cost would be ₹80,000, as compared to ₹30,000 (3% fee) for a company with a good credit score. This difference of ₹50,000 can severely strain a business’s profitability.

Takeaway: Before opting for invoice discounting, FMCG companies should work on improving their credit score by maintaining a good credit history, timely payments, and strong financial management practices.

  1. Reduced Profit Margins

Explanation: The fees associated with invoice discounting can reduce the profit margins of FMCG businesses, particularly those operating on low margins. FMCG companies usually have a high sales volume at a lower per-unit margin. This means that even small financing costs can impact their overall profitability.

For instance, if an FMCG company operates on a profit margin of 10% and the invoice discounting fee is around 3-5% of the invoice value, a substantial portion of its profit margin is lost to financing costs. Over time, this reduction can affect the company’s ability to reinvest in growth and operations.

  • Practical Impact: This reduced profitability can be problematic, especially in competitive markets where FMCG businesses must balance costs and pricing to maintain market share.
  • Example: Suppose an FMCG business generates ₹50,00,000 in revenue and typically earns a net profit of ₹5,00,000 (10%). If it uses invoice discounting at a 4% fee, it will incur ₹2,00,000 in financing costs, reducing its net profit to ₹3,00,000. This can hinder the company’s ability to expand, invest in marketing, or increase production.

Takeaway: FMCG businesses need to carefully analyse the impact of invoice discounting fees on their profit margins. While it may not be viable for high-volume, low-margin products, it could be more suitable for higher-margin goods.

  1. Risk of Over-Reliance

Explanation: One of the less obvious but critical risks associated with invoice discounting is the potential for over-reliance. For businesses facing cash flow issues, the ease and speed of obtaining funds through invoice discounting can lead to a dependency on this financing tool. Over time, companies may rely on discounted invoices for regular cash flow management, creating a vicious cycle of short-term borrowing.

This over-reliance can be dangerous, as it masks underlying financial problems like poor cash flow management, ineffective credit control, or inconsistent sales. If the business continues to depend heavily on invoice discounting, it might face a liquidity crunch when this financing source is no longer available or becomes too expensive.

  • Practical Impact: Relying too much on invoice discounting can signal financial instability to suppliers and investors, who may question the business’s sustainability.
  • Example: An FMCG company that uses invoice discounting for every batch of sales may focus on something other than improving its internal cash flow processes. If one major customer delays payment, the entire cash flow cycle could collapse, leading to disruptions in operations.

Takeaway: Invoice discounting should be a temporary or supplementary tool rather than a long-term solution. Businesses should concurrently strengthen their cash flow management strategies and reduce dependency on external financing.

  1. Volatility in Cash Flow

Explanation: Invoice discounting is highly dependent on customers’ timely payment of invoices. Any delays or customer defaults can lead to cash flow volatility, disrupting the business’s financial stability. Unlike traditional loans, where payments are structured and predictable, invoice discounting’s cash inflow is tied to the unpredictable nature of customer payments.

This can be particularly challenging for FMCG companies, which often deal with large retail clients and distributors. If a large retailer delays payment, the FMCG company might face difficulties repaying the discounting fee or maintaining liquidity for day-to-day operations.

  • Practical Impact: Delayed payments can incur additional charges or penalties, increasing the finance cost. In extreme cases, it may force the business to take out further loans to bridge the gap, leading to a debt trap.
  • Example: Suppose an FMCG manufacturer discounts an invoice of ₹20,00,000 with a large retailer, expecting payment in 30 days. If the retailer delays payment for 60 days, the manufacturer’s cash flow can be severely affected, disrupting their ability to pay suppliers and produce new inventory.

Takeaway: FMCG companies using invoice discounting must have robust credit control processes and ensure that they work with reliable customers. They should also maintain a cash reserve to manage any volatility due to delayed payments.

  1. Not Suitable for All Business Sizes

Explanation: Invoice discounting is typically more beneficial for larger FMCG firms with high sales turnover, established credit control, and strong customer relationships. Smaller FMCG companies may need help accessing invoice discounting due to high costs, lack of sufficient invoices, or inconsistent sales patterns. This makes it less viable for startups or small businesses with fewer clients or irregular sales cycles.

For smaller FMCG businesses, invoice discounting costs may outweigh the benefits, especially if they are already facing profitability challenges. Moreover, many financial institutions prefer working with larger firms with stable cash flows and a proven track record.

  • Practical Impact: Small businesses may find that invoice discounting is unsuitable due to the stringent eligibility criteria and high discounting fees, pushing them towards more traditional financing tools like short-term loans or credit lines.
  • Example: A small FMCG firm with annual sales of ₹1 crore may not have the scale to justify the high costs of invoice discounting. Any delay or default could jeopardise its entire cash flow if it has only a few large customers.

Takeaway: Smaller FMCG companies should explore other financing options before invoice discounting. Building solid customer relationships and improving internal cash flow management might provide a more sustainable solution.

Practical Tips for Implementing Invoice Discounting Effectively

  1. Choose the Right Type: Decide between full or selective invoice discounting based on your cash flow needs and the size of your business. For smaller FMCG firms, selective invoice discounting can be more cost-effective.
  2. Negotiate Fees: Always negotiate the fees based on your company’s credit score, invoice volume, and financial health. Robust credit control can help secure lower fees.
  3. Use It Strategically: Refrain from over-rely on invoice discounting. Use it as a tactical tool during high-demand seasons or when expanding into new markets.
  4. Monitor Customer Payment Patterns: Late customer payments can lead to high interest charges. Implement strong credit control practices to mitigate this risk.
  5. Maintain Transparency with Stakeholders: Ensure suppliers and partners know your financing strategy to avoid potential misunderstandings about financial health.

Final Words

Invoice discounting is a powerful tool for FMCG businesses looking to unlock cash tied up in unpaid invoices. It offers quick access to funds, enhanced cash flow, and flexibility, making it ideal for companies with high credit sales. However, businesses must consider costs, manage over-reliance risks, and use this tool strategically. By weighing the pros and cons, FMCG companies can make informed decisions to leverage invoice discounting effectively, ensuring sustainable growth and profitability.

CashnTech provides the best invoice discounting services tailored to the unique needs of FMCG businesses. It helps them manage cash flow efficiently and stay competitive in the market. With a focus on flexibility, transparency, and reliable support, CashnTech is a trusted partner for businesses looking to optimise their working capital.

FAQs

  1. What is invoice discounting in FMCG?
    Invoice discounting is a financing tool where FMCG companies use unpaid invoices as collateral to receive immediate cash advances. 
  2. How does invoice discounting benefit FMCG companies?
    It improves cash flow, provides quick access to funds, and allows businesses to invest in growth opportunities without waiting for customer payments. 
  3. What are the costs associated with invoice discounting?
    Typically, fees range from 3% to 5% of the invoice value, depending on the company’s size, sector, and credit rating. 
  4. Is invoice discounting suitable for small FMCG businesses?
    It is more suited for larger companies with high sales turnover. Smaller firms should evaluate the costs and benefits carefully. 
  5. What are the risks of invoice discounting?
    The main risks include reduced profit margins, over-reliance on short-term financing, and volatility in cash flow due to delayed payments.

Leave a Reply